The Call of Earth
Year: 1993
Author: Orson Scott Card
Length: 641 minutes / 10.68 hours
After being so disappointed with The Memory of Earth, I’m surprised I gave the second volume in the Homecoming series a chance. I figured Orson Scott Card could have got things on track by this book, getting rid of all the unnecessary fluff and useless ramblings. Instead, The Call of Earth made it clear to me that I will not be continuing this series. Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me.
I think part of the problem with this series is how it’s written. Having recently read an eye-opening book on identifying “Show versus Tell,” it shocked me how much of this book was written with “Tell” language. Granted, a lot of science fiction and fantasy books have to do this to explain interesting magic or technologies. The Call of Earth, however, spent another whole book stuck in this pseudo-Roman society that most people can easily visualize. I’m still convinced he threw this series together to meet a deadline, because it has never felt that inspired.
What’s most frustrating is knowing that it could be better. I was expecting this book to be about leaving their planet in search of Earth. Instead, they merely talked about it for 10 hours. None of the characters stood out to me, and whatever plot was there was so forgettable, I don’t even care to look up what it was. I get that not every author is going to have all their books be amazing or thought-provoking. But two in a row doesn’t give me much hope that the other three books in this series will be any better.
Another disappointing entry in Card’s Homecoming series, I give The Call of Earth 2.0 stars out of 5.
